Why you shouldn’t email passwords

Email feels like a private letter. In practice it behaves more like a filing cabinet with several keys: built to keep everything, indexed for search and copied to more places than you’d guess. That’s useful for almost everything you send, and exactly wrong for a password.

Where an emailed password actually ends up

Press send, and from then on the password can exist in all of these places:

  • your Sent folder and the recipient’s inbox, for as long as anyone keeps them;
  • each phone, tablet and laptop that syncs either mailbox;
  • server backups and any compliance archive, on both sides;
  • the quoted text of every reply and forward that follows;
  • the mailboxes of anyone later copied into the thread.

Nobody is being careless here. That is simply email working as designed, and no setting on your side reaches the copies held on theirs.

A mailbox is what attackers search first

Email accounts get compromised through phishing and through passwords reused from other sites. Whoever gets in doesn’t need to read everything. They can type “password”, “login” or the name of your hosting company into the search box, and years of correspondence hand over whatever is in there. A password sent long ago and forgotten is still found, and it may well still work.

You get no signal when something goes wrong

An email can’t tell you who read it. If your message was forwarded to a colleague, opened on a shared computer or read by an intruder, nothing changes on your screen. Read receipts are optional and easy to decline, and they don’t tell you who was at the keyboard. Email also has no expiry and no recall you can rely on once a message has left your organisation.

Why “just this once” adds up

Each emailed password seems harmless because it’s one message. But the risk comes from what accumulates: every hosting login, database password and client account sent the same way over the years, sitting in one searchable place. It often goes unnoticed until the day someone else has that search box.

If you’ve already emailed a password

You can’t recall it, but you can make it worthless. In order of importance:

  1. Change the password. That is the only step that fully deals with every copy. Send the replacement some other way.
  2. Check whether it was reused anywhere else, and change it there as well.
  3. Turn on two-factor authentication if the account offers it.
  4. Search your own mailbox for other credentials and deal with those the same way. Deleting the messages is worthwhile tidying, but it comes after changing the passwords, not instead of it.

What to do instead

Keep using email for the conversation, and take the secret out of it. With a one-time secret link, the message carries a link to the password rather than the password. Once it’s been opened it is destroyed, so what remains in the inbox, the backups and the reply chain opens nothing.

It is not magic. Until the link is opened, anyone who can read that email can use it. The difference is that you’ll know: you get a timestamp when it’s opened, and your recipient sees a message saying it has already been read if somebody got there first. You can also withdraw an unopened link from your dashboard at any time.

One practical point if you use the built-in email option: the short note you can add to that email is ordinary email text, so keep the password out of it. Our guide to sharing a password securely covers the rest of the routine.

Common questions

Is it safe to email a password if I delete it afterwards?
Not really. Deleting removes your copy from your mailbox, eventually. It does nothing to the recipient’s copy, to copies on their devices, or to backups and archives on either side.
What if I send the password in a protected document?
That only moves the problem: you now need a safe way to deliver the document’s password, and sending it in a second email to the same inbox protects very little. The protected file also stays in the mailbox, where it can be attacked at leisure.
Isn’t email encrypted these days?
Often in transit between mail servers, but that protects a message on the move, not one sitting in a mailbox. Anyone who gets into the mailbox reads it as normal, and as a sender you generally can’t tell how every step of the route was handled.
Is emailing a one-time link any different?
Yes. The email holds a link rather than the secret, and once that link has been opened or has expired, what’s left in the inbox opens nothing. Until then, the link is as sensitive as the secret, which is why short expiry times are worth using.

Send your next secret as a one-time link

Free to use. Create an account and confirm your email address, then the link is yours to send. Whoever receives it doesn’t need an account.

Create a secret

More guides

All guides

Host Dada Secrets is one of the tools from Host Dada. Read more on the Host Dada one-time secret tool page.